CPG · Answer

Does selling pet insurance through a retailer work?

A member discount on a named insurer does; a store-brand plan mostly doesn’t. “Costco pet insurance” draws 33,100 searches a month, and one in five Google reviews of Figo, Costco’s insurer, names Costco. Chewy’s three CarePlus terms draw 5,090 between them, “careplus” is falling, and Chewy calls these service revenues not material to net sales. PetSmart’s Healthy Paws partnership appears in none of 86 reviews.

The evidence

Channel search is a third of an insurer's.

Searches for cover by the company that sells it total 46,600 a month, 34.5% of the 135,000 for “lemonade pet insurance”. We registered under 10% and missed.

Filings point the same way.

State rate filings for Chewy's Trupanion-backed plan showed a few hundred policies in its top states about 18 months after launch. Trupanion's 10-K names vet hospitals, not retailers, as its largest referral source.

The channel that converts has the worst claims record.

Figo averages 1.9 stars across 97 reviews, and 20 mention a denied claim, the highest share of seven insurers.

What would have to be true for this to be wrong

If a retailer published uptake at the point of offer, or if channel customers showed up in reviews in proportion to channel search, this reading would change. Searches, filings and reviews are proxies, not conversion.

Google Ads search volume and Google reviews via DataForSEO, United States, runs 7b48c2bb, 12337d6f and c5678f59. Chewy FY2025 and Trupanion 10-K filings; Coverager on state filings.
Every row behind this answer is published in the standing study at cultmath.com/research/cpg/pet-insurance-gap, which is re-run on a schedule and corrected in place, dated.
Published 2026-11-12 by Ipalibo Da-Wariboko, CULT+MATH LLC. Where a number could not be sourced, this page says so and gives none.

This is one of six decisions covered in the cpg decision brief — each with the evidence behind it, who owns it, who it is contested with, and what would have to be true for the answer to flip.

$495 · PDF on payment · 14-day guarantee

Sample page 1 of CPG Decision Brief 01 — The Brand ManagerFinal page of CPG Decision Brief 01 — The Brand Manager