Study · CPG · Six lenses, registered before the data

Pet owners know insurance exists. They doubt it pays.

Fewer than one US dog or cat in twenty is insured, while vet prices have risen almost twice as fast as everything else. We read the gap through demand against supply, consumers, competitors, collaborators, critics and context, for a pet brand deciding whether to put cover in front of its customers. The gap is not awareness.

Read this first. The only count of insured pets comes from the insurers’ own trade body. The reviews are Google reviews of each insurer’s office listing, written by people who chose to write. The lead explanation’s search test missed, and is reported below as a miss.

Ipalibo Da-Wariboko · CULT+MATH · November 12, 2026 · 559 reviews · 28 searched terms · 12 assistant answers · public data only, nothing commissioned

4.27% of US dogs and cats are insured: 5.99% of dogs, 2.29% of cats.

Owners already know cover exists: they search for the price and how it works about four times as often as they ask whether it is worth it. Where they talk, and where they review, the argument is whether it pays, and the most common complaint is a denied claim. Sold through a retailer, a member discount on a named insurer (Costco and Figo) draws buyers; a store-brand wrapper (Chewy CarePlus) mostly doesn’t.

6.98 million insured of 163.6 million owned · awareness searches 42,970 a month, worth-it searches 11,360 · “denied” in 49 of 559 reviews

The decision this is for

Whether a pet brand should put an insurance offer in front of its customers, and through which model. The seat is the head of growth or partnerships at a US pet food, supplies or retail brand.

If owners don’t buy because nobody asked them at the right moment, an offer closes the gap. If they don’t buy because they doubt it pays, an offer that doesn’t answer that doubt adds nothing. The evidence points to the second, with one exception worth copying.

Demand against supply

The gap, and the pressure on it
MeasureFigure
Insured dogs and cats, end of 20256.98M
Owned dogs and cats (AVMA count)163.6M
Share insured4.27%
Dogs insured / cats insured5.99% / 2.29%
Cats as a share of insured pets / of owned pets25% / 47%
Insured pets, growth in 2025+9%
North American premium, growth in 2025$6.2B, +19.4%
Vet prices against all prices, 2019 to 2025+47% / +26%

Premium grew about twice as fast as the number of pets covered, so the money is coming from repricing faster than from reaching new owners. Cats are under-covered, and their owners also search for cover far less, which points at lower demand as much as at insurers leaving them out.

Owners search like shoppers

What it is, how it works, what it costs: average monthly US searches
SearchPer month
pet insurance quote14,800
how much is pet insurance9,900
pet insurance cost5,400
how does pet insurance work4,400
what does pet insurance cover4,400
what is pet insurance1,900
how to get pet insurance1,600
where to get pet insurance390
how does pet insurance reimbursement work110
pet insurance explained70
Total42,970
Whether it is worth it, and whether it pays: average monthly US searches
SearchPer month
is pet insurance worth it9,900
is pet insurance a scam590
pet insurance worth it480
do i need pet insurance320
pet insurance premium increase30
pet insurance not worth it20
pet insurance claim denied10
pet insurance denied claim10
Total11,360

Doubt in search is almost one question, is pet insurance worth it. Searches about denied claims and premium rises barely register, even though they lead the critics’ case. Owners decide before they buy, and the ones who decide against it don’t search for grievances. In public forums the balance flips: self-insuring and worth-it doubt outnumber “didn’t know it existed” by about seven to one, on a small sample.

Who sells it: the channel test

Searches for cover by the company that sells it, average per month
SearchPer month
costco pet insurance33,100
chewy pet insurance4,400
geico pet insurance4,400
petco pet insurance1,300
walmart pet insurance1,300
petsmart pet insurance1,000
chewy careplus480
aflac pet insurance320
careplus pet insurance210
pet insurance through employer90
Total46,600

Channel searches total 34.5% of the 135,000 a month for “lemonade pet insurance”. Costco alone draws 33,100 a month, near the big insurers’ own names. Chewy’s three terms draw 5,090, and “careplus” searches are falling.

Chewy’s own 10-K files its insurance revenue inside “other” sales and calls these service revenues not a material component of net sales. State rate filings for Chewy’s Trupanion-backed plan showed a few hundred policies in its top states about 18 months after launch. Trupanion’s 10-K names veterinary hospitals as its largest referral source.

What buyers say afterwards

The 100 newest Google reviews of each insurer's office listing
InsurerRetail partnerReviewsAvg ratingMention deniedName the partner
Healthy PawsPetSmart (since Aug 2025)864.22.3%0 of 86 name PetSmart
EmbraceGEICO793.83.8%—
Spot—953.59.5%—
TrupanionChewy CarePlus973.46.2%1 of 97 name Chewy
Nationwide—893.47.9%—
FigoCostco members971.920.6%20 of 97 name Costco
Pets Best—161.912.5%—
Complaint themes across all 559 reviews
ThemeReviewsShare
denied49 of 5598.8%
pre-existing32 of 5595.7%
cancel23 of 5594.1%
worth22 of 5593.9%
increase or went up20 of 5593.6%

Where a channel has real volume, its customers show up: one in five Figo reviews names Costco. Chewy appears in one Trupanion review; PetSmart, whose Healthy Paws partnership began in August 2025, in none. After buying, the complaint is a denied claim, about two and a half times as often as a price rise. Denial share runs from about 2% to about 21% across insurers, and the insurer behind the channel that converts has the highest.

What the assistant tells a buyer

We asked ChatGPT six buyer questions, twice each. Asked why so few owners have pet insurance, it listed lack of awareness first in both runs, without searching the web. Asked for the best pet insurance, it gave the same five insurers in the same order both times, with no retailer and without Trupanion, the largest US underwriter. Asked where to buy, it listed only insurers. It named a retailer only when the question named stores, and then Chewy first, in both runs.

What we got wrong

I expected doubt to lead in search, and it trailed almost four to one. The lead explanation survives only because the brief required both search and owners’ own words to go against it, and the words did not. Price questions count as awareness here, as registered; read them as affordability and the two sides tie. I also expected channel searches to be negligible. Costco made them a third of an insurer’s.

Registered predictions and what happened
PredictionRegisteredResult
Under 10% of US dogs and cats are insured85%Hit (4.27%)
Cats are under-covered against their share of owned pets70%Hit (25% of insured, 47% of owned)
Vet prices rose faster than all prices over five years75%Hit (+47% against +26%)
Worth-it searches outnumber what-is and how-to searches60%Miss (11,360 against 42,970)
Asked for the best pet insurance, ChatGPT names no retailer65%Hit (both runs)
Store channels appear in under 5% of insurer reviews75%Hit (3.9%)
"Denied" is the most common complaint theme60%Hit (49 of 559)
Channel searches total under 10% of Lemonade's70%Miss (34.5%)

What this cannot tell you

No uptake figure exists at any point of offer. No retailer, employer or vet publishes how many people buy when cover is offered. The channel readings here are searches, filings and reviews, not conversion.

Reviews are not a policyholder sample. A listing with thousands of reviews and a high rating may be asking customers to review after a paid claim. Lemonade’s office listing has six reviews across all its lines and is left out.

Regulators will publish better data. The NAIC now collects pet insurance results, including claims closed without payment and complaints per 1,000 policies, starting with the 2024 reporting year. When those ratios are public they supersede the review counts here.

How it was built

A registered brief named four explanations and their odds before any source was opened, then two amendments added complaints and reviews, each registered before its data. Market counts come from NAPHIA, AVMA and BLS; channel evidence from Chewy’s and Trupanion’s 10-Ks and state filings; demand, answers and reviews from DataForSEO. Nothing was commissioned and no company was contacted. Runs 59b420a6 · f2afb92b · 869e488b · 7b48c2bb · 12337d6f · c5678f59.

Whether to sell cover is one of the decisions a brand owns

This study answers one partnership question for a pet brand. The CPG Decision Brief takes the six decisions a brand manager owns and answers each from filings, with the limits of the evidence stated.

See the six decisions

$495 standard, $995 custom. Pre-made and delivered on payment. If the decision turns out not to be decidable from evidence, it is refunded.

CULT+MATH LLC · Houston, Texas · Ipalibo Da-Wariboko
Standing research. Figures are re-measured on the schedule stated on each page and the page is corrected in place, dated. Corrections are published, not applied quietly.
Cite as: CULT+MATH LLC, Ipalibo Da-Wariboko. Attribution to cultmath.com is requested.