CPG · Answer

What do pet insurance customers complain about?

Denied claims, most of all. In the newest Google reviews of seven US pet insurers, 559 in all, 49 mention a denied claim, 32 pre-existing conditions, 23 canceling, 22 whether it is worth it and 20 price. A denied claim comes up about two and a half times as often as a price rise. Denial share runs from about 2% of reviews (Healthy Paws) to about 21% (Figo).

The evidence

Ratings spread widely.

Healthy Paws averages 4.2 stars, Embrace 3.8, Spot 3.5, Trupanion and Nationwide 3.4, Figo and Pets Best 1.9.

Search doesn't show it.

Searches about denied claims and premium rises barely register next to “is pet insurance worth it”. Owners decide before buying; the grievance shows up afterwards.

Better data is coming.

The NAIC now collects pet insurance results, including claims closed without payment and complaints per 1,000 policies, from the 2024 reporting year. They are not yet public.

What would have to be true for this to be wrong

Reviews are written by people who chose to write, about each insurer's office listing, so they are not a policyholder sample. When the NAIC ratios are published they supersede these counts. Lemonade had six reviews and is left out.

Google reviews via DataForSEO, the 100 newest per listing, November 2026, runs 12337d6f and c5678f59. NAIC pet insurance data call.
Every row behind this answer is published in the standing study at cultmath.com/research/cpg/pet-insurance-gap, which is re-run on a schedule and corrected in place, dated.
Published 2026-11-12 by Ipalibo Da-Wariboko, CULT+MATH LLC. Where a number could not be sourced, this page says so and gives none.

This is one of six decisions covered in the cpg decision brief — each with the evidence behind it, who owns it, who it is contested with, and what would have to be true for the answer to flip.

$495 · PDF on payment · 14-day guarantee

Sample page 1 of CPG Decision Brief 01 — The Brand ManagerFinal page of CPG Decision Brief 01 — The Brand Manager