Costco sells pet insurance. Chewy mostly doesn’t.
Fewer than one US dog or cat in twenty is insured. Owners already know cover exists; what they doubt is that it pays. For a pet brand weighing an insurance offer, the model decides more than the reach.
Every pet brand with a large customer list eventually gets the same pitch from an insurer. Your customers own pets, vet bills are rising, almost none of them are covered, and you already have their attention. Put our plan in front of them, with your name on it if you like, and share the revenue.
The pitch rests on one assumption: that owners go uninsured because nobody offered them cover at the right moment. If that is true, a brand with reach closes the gap. If owners go uninsured because they doubt it pays, an offer that doesn’t answer the doubt adds a logo and little else. We tested which it is, before pulling any data, from six directions: the market count, what owners search for, what they say, what AI assistants tell them, what the retailers already selling it report, and what buyers write afterwards.
The need is real, and it is growing
Share of US dogs and cats with insurance at the end of 2025: 6.98 million of 163.6 million. Dogs 5.99%, cats 2.29%.
Vet prices rose 47% from 2019 to 2025, against 26% for all prices, by the Bureau of Labor Statistics. Insured pets grew 9% last year, and North American premium grew 19.4% to $6.2 billion. Premium growing twice as fast as pets covered means insurers are earning more from repricing the owners they have than from reaching new ones. The count itself comes from the insurers’ own trade body; on a different ownership count it is closer to 3.6%. Either way, the gap is most of the market.
They search like shoppers and talk like doubters
If owners didn’t know cover existed, they wouldn’t search for its price. They do, far more than anything else.
Google Ads monthly search volume via DataForSEO, United States, run 59b420a6. Price questions are counted with awareness, as registered; counted as doubt, the two sides roughly tie.
The doubt that does show up in search is almost one question. Searches about denied claims and premium rises barely register. In public forums the balance flips: on a small sample of owners explaining their choice, self-insuring and worth-it doubt outnumbered “I didn’t know it existed” by about seven to one. Owners look up the price, decide it doesn’t pay, and stop searching.
ChatGPT tells buyers otherwise. Asked why so few owners have pet insurance, it put lack of awareness first in both of two runs, without looking anything up. Asked for the best pet insurance, it named the same five insurers in the same order both times, with no retailer and without Trupanion, the largest US underwriter. It named a retailer only when the question named stores.
One retail model draws buyers
Several large retailers already sell cover, so the channel question has been run in the market. Searches for pet insurance by the company that sells it total 46,600 a month, about a third of the searches for Lemonade, one of the largest direct insurers. Almost all of that is one name.
Google Ads monthly search volume via DataForSEO, United States, run 7b48c2bb. Chewy combines “chewy pet insurance”, “chewy careplus” and “careplus”.
Costco offers its members a discount on a plan underwritten and named by Figo. Chewy sells CarePlus, its own-label plan backed by Trupanion, to one of the largest pet customer files in the country. Costco draws more than six times Chewy’s searches. Chewy’s 10-K for fiscal 2025 files insurance inside “other” net sales of $406.8 million, down 4.7%, and calls these service revenues not a material component of net sales. State rate filings showed a few hundred CarePlus policies in each of its top states in early 2024. Trupanion’s own 10-K names vet hospitals, not retailers, as its largest referral source.
Reviews show who actually bought where. One in five Figo reviews names Costco. One Trupanion review mentions Chewy. PetSmart, whose Healthy Paws partnership began in August 2025, appears in none of 86.
The complaint is the claim, not the price
We read the newest Google reviews of seven insurers, 559 in all, and coded each for what it complained about. A denied claim came up 49 times, pre-existing conditions 32, canceling 23, worth it 22 and price 20.
Google reviews via DataForSEO, the newest 100 per insurer’s office listing, runs 12337d6f and c5678f59. Pets Best had 16 reviews. Lemonade had six and is left out.
The retail model that converts sits on the insurer with the worst record. Figo averages 1.9 stars and one in five of its reviewers mentions a denied claim, the highest share of the seven. A brand that copies the Costco structure with that kind of partner wins the sale and then owns the complaint. Reviews are written by people who chose to write, so these are not policyholder rates; the NAIC has begun collecting claims-denied and complaint ratios from the 2024 reporting year, and when they publish they replace these counts.
Two predictions missed
We expected worth-it searches to outnumber awareness searches. They trailed almost four to one. The doubt explanation survives only because the brief required search and owners’ own words both to go against it, and the words didn’t. We also expected searches by sales channel to be negligible, under a tenth of an insurer’s. Costco alone made them a third. Both misses are on the study page with every row.
- Your customers already pay a membership or subscription that a discount can attach to. Costco’s offer rides on a fee members already chose to pay.
- The insurer keeps its own name on the plan, and you can read its claim record before you sign: denial share in reviews today, NAIC ratios once published.
- The offer answers whether it pays with your customers’ own likely vet costs, not with the existence of cover.
- You have a reason to sell it that isn’t the revenue share, because at Chewy’s scale the revenue was not material.
If none of the four holds, an insurance offer is a referral link with your brand’s name on the complaints. If the first two hold, the Costco model is the one in this market with buyers behind it.
- CEO 95.7% of US dogs and cats are uninsured, and owners doubt cover pays rather than don’t know of it. Offer cover only as an answer to that doubt, not as another place to buy it.
- CFO Chewy, with one of the largest pet customer files, calls this revenue not material. Model the offer as a retention cost, not a profit line, and cap it accordingly.
- CRO Costco’s discount draws 33,100 searches a month against about 5,000 for Chewy’s own-label plan. Attach a member discount to a named insurer rather than putting your name on the plan.
- CPO Owners search for the price 42,970 times a month and ask whether it pays 11,360. Build the offer around a cost check on the customer’s own pet, not a quote form.
- Legal A denied claim is the top theme in 559 reviews, and a co-branded plan carries the brand into it. Contract for claim-handling standards and the right to exit on published denial ratios.
- Risk The insurer behind the converting channel has the highest denial share of seven, at one in five reviews. Choose the partner on claims record before reach or rate.
Reconciled. The CRO seat pulls toward the Costco structure because it is the one with buyers; the Risk and Legal seats pull against it because the insurer behind it has the worst claims record here. The CFO seat says the revenue won’t justify much either way. One course satisfies most of them: a member discount on a named insurer chosen first for its claims record, offered alongside a plain cost check on the customer’s own pet, and treated as a loyalty benefit rather than a revenue line.
Screen the partner on claims before the term sheet.
Before any insurance partnership reaches a term sheet, pull the newest 100 Google reviews of each shortlisted insurer and count the share that mention a denied claim. Drop any partner above one in ten. Then run the offer as a member-only discount to one customer segment for a quarter, with a vet-cost check on the landing page.
- What it costs
- A day of an analyst’s time and a few dollars of review data for the screen, then one quarter’s placement in a member channel. It may also cost the partner with the best rate.
- How you’ll know
- Branded searches for your name plus “pet insurance” rise within the quarter, and reviews of the partner start naming your brand. Neither moving by quarter end means the doubt wasn’t answered.
Decide the partnership on the claims record, with the evidence in hand.
The CPG Decision Brief takes the six decisions a brand manager owns, partnerships among them, and answers each from sourced, dated filings with the limits stated. Or commission one built around your own customers and shortlist.
See the CPG Decision Brief Or commission a custom brief →