St. Paul’s permits fell after rent stabilization. Minneapolis’s fell further.
St. Paul voters approved rent stabilization in November 2021, and it took effect in May 2022. The city exempted new construction permanently in 2025. We compared St. Paul’s housing permits before and after with Minneapolis next door, over the same years.
Read this first. One neighboring city is a comparison, not a control group. This study does not say whether rent stabilization is good or bad policy; it says what the permit record shows and what it cannot separate.
St. Paul fell 43%. Minneapolis fell 50%.
Average yearly units permitted, 2018–2021 against 2022–2024: St. Paul went from 1,620 to 926, Minneapolis from 3,740 to 1,887. A drop of similar size in both cities points to a regional slump in building as much as to anything specific to St. Paul.
The decision this is for
Whether the 2025 amendments are enough, or the ordinance needs further change. The seat is Mayor Kaohly Her, sworn in in January 2026. The council exempted all new construction permanently on May 7, 2025, effective June 13, 2025.
Permits in both cities, year by year
| City | 2015 | 2016 | 2017 | 2018 | 2019 | 2020 | 2021 | 2022 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| St. Paul | 923 | 930 | 309 | 706 | 1,575 | 2,077 | 2,120 | 1,169 | 1,204 | 404 | 357 |
| Minneapolis | 1,489 | 2,908 | 2,254 | 3,625 | 4,813 | 3,340 | 3,182 | 3,681 | 1,528 | 452 | 412 |
Buildings of five or more units carried the drop in St. Paul: from 1,556 a year to 820. And 2025 brought no rebound in either city: St. Paul permitted 357 units against 404 in 2024. The permanent exemption was in force for only half of 2025.
What happened to rent
| 2019 | 2023 | 2024 | 2025 | US 2025 | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Population | 308,096 | 303,827 | 307,484 | 306,665 | 341,784,859 |
| Median gross rent | $1,001 | $1,314 | $1,247 | $1,328 | $1,557 |
| Median household income | $63,174 | $73,975 | $70,182 | $81,802 | $84,780 |
| Renters paying 30%+ of income | 48.4% | 48.5% | 49.1% | 45.3% | 51.8% |
| Workers who work from home | 5.6% | 19.0% | 14.2% | 15.7% | 12.9% |
St. Paul’s median gross rent rose 32.7% from 2019 to 2025, Minneapolis’s 30.9%, the nation’s 41.9%. The survey measures what all renters pay, not only the units the ordinance covers.
How the predictions did
| Prediction | Registered | Result |
|---|---|---|
| St. Paul's 2022–2024 permits, as a share of 2018–2021, are lower than Minneapolis's same ratio | roughly even | Missed: 57% against 50% |
| St. Paul's permits in buildings of five or more fell from 2018–2021 to 2022–2024 | likely | Held |
| St. Paul permitted more units in 2025 than in 2024 | roughly even | Missed: 357 against 404 |
What this cannot tell you
The two cities differ in more than the ordinance. Minneapolis’s earlier boom was larger, so it had further to fall. Under the brief’s registered rule, a gap within 10 percentage points supports the regional-slump explanation; the gap is 7 points.
City limits, not the region. Growth in the suburbs is outside every figure here. Cause is not tested. Interest rates and construction costs hit all five cities at once; five cities can show what moved, not why. Survey estimates carry margins of error; we treat changes under 5% as about flat.
How it was built
One brief per city, written and dated before any data was pulled, named the question, the decision, the competing explanations and the predictions. The figures are from U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 1-year estimates (2019, 2023, 2024, 2025; the 2025 release of October 29, 2026) and Building Permits Survey annual place files, 2015–2025, read on November 16, 2026. The same pull ran for five Midwest cities so each is a peer for the others: see all five side by side.
Run it for your city
The same Census figures and the same permit check, for any US city of 65,000 or more residents. With CULT+MATH connected, ask your AI assistant: “Run a city profile for Boise, Idaho.” Connect CULT+MATH. Agents call run_city_profile, or POST {"state":"ID","place":"Boise"} to https://cultmath.com/run/city-profile.
What a Decision Brief does with this
These studies measure a city against its own stated goal. A Decision Brief does the same for one executive seat: six decisions, each answered from evidence, with the limits stated.
See the Decision Briefs$495 standard, $995 custom. Pre-made and delivered on payment. If the decision turns out not to be decidable from evidence, it is refunded.