Decisions · Brand & Demand

Robert and Michelle King built three shows from one character

The Good Wife, The Good Fight and Elsbeth are one portfolio with three different reasons to watch. Launching the new one never lifted the old one, and AI assistants still recommend the shows that have ended.

Every brand team with a hit eventually holds the same meeting. Something worked, and the question on the table is what to build next from it. Somebody says "extension," somebody says "the halo will carry it," and a budget gets sized on the assumption that the new product and the old one will feed each other.

Robert and Michelle King have held that meeting three times with one set of characters. The Good Wife ran on CBS from 2009 to 2016. The Good Fight ran only on streaming, on CBS All Access and then Paramount+, from 2017 to 2022. Elsbeth went back to CBS in 2024 and opened its fourth season on October 8, 2026.

That is usually called a franchise. It reads better as a product portfolio: one source of characters, three products, each built for a different channel and a different buyer. So we checked three things a brand lead would want to know before making the same call. Why people love each product. Whether launching the new one lifted the old one. And what AI assistants now tell people about the family.

Two shows, two different reasons to watch

We read 25 professional reviews and creator interviews and sorted them by the reason each gave for liking the show.

Audience voice · Reasons cited, by show
THE GOOD FIGHTELSBETHPolitics80Writing61Representation50Characters210Format15Reviews and interviews citing each reason · 13 for The Good Fight, 12 for Elsbeth

Each review or interview can cite more than one reason. Sources include NPR, The Hollywood Reporter, The Ringer, The Week, Pajiba, AV Club, TheWrap and CinemaBlend.

The Good Fight is loved for what it says. Critics called it the sharpest political drama of the Trump years. Its central law firm is written as a prestigious African American–owned firm built on police-brutality cases, and The Ringer singled out its Black lawyers as complex people who disagree with each other, which the parent show rarely gave its Black characters.

Elsbeth is loved for who she is: a wide-eyed, oddly dressed lawyer everyone underestimates, who turns out to be the smartest person in the room. The Hollywood Reporter called it the Kings in “comfort-food mode.”

The two lists barely overlap, and that was the plan. The Kings have said Elsbeth is a different genre with a different tone, built from rewatching Columbo. They have also explained why The Good Fight was too niche for broadcast. The edgier product went where a narrow audience pays. The warmer one went where a broad audience watches for free.

Not when it launched

If a spin-off lifts its parent, it should show up in the month the spin-off premieres, when the promotion is loudest. We set the bar before looking: a parent show’s US search volume had to rise at least 20% against the three months before. We added a second family from another studio, Suits and Suits LA, to check the pattern was not the Kings’ alone.

The Number
None of 6

Spin-off premiere months in which searches for the parent show cleared the 20% lift bar. The best result was +14%. The worst was −42%.

Google Ads search volume via DataForSEO, United States, monthly, 2019 to September 2026
Premiere months · Parent searches against the bar
+30%+20%+10%0-10%-20%-30%-40%THE BAR · +20% = LIFT-7%Good WifeFeb 2024+13%Good WifeMar 2024-7%Good WifeOct 2024+14%Good WifeOct 2025-8%SuitsFeb 2025-42%SuitsMar 2025PARENT-SHOW SEARCHES IN A SPIN-OFF PREMIERE MONTH, VS THE 3 MONTHS BEFORE

The spin-offs drew far more attention than their parents did. Searches for Elsbeth peaked at 550,000 a month in April 2024, nearly three times The Good Wife’s best month. Suits LA reached 1.2 million searches in its launch month while Suits sat near 40,000.

Search interest · Elsbeth against The Good Wife
0200K400K600KELSBETH S1ELSBETH S2ELSBETH S32023202420252026MONTHLY US GOOGLE SEARCHESELSBETHTHE GOOD WIFEPeak: Elsbeth 550K (Apr 2024) · The Good Wife 201K (May 2024)

The Good Wife roughly doubled between 2019 and 2025, from about 73,000 searches a month to about 141,000, without jumping in any premiere month.

That slow climb is the one open thread. It could be a slow halo, or a streaming deal putting the old show in front of new people. This test cannot tell those apart. What it rules out is the version most budgets assume, the one where a launch sends buyers back to the original.

CBS had a reason to expect this. By Robert King’s account, the network’s focus groups found that few people knew The Good Wife or The Good Fight at all, so Elsbeth was built to need neither. The parent brand was more famous inside the building than outside it.

We wrote our predictions down before pulling the data. We gave the halo even odds. It missed.

The machines know the old shows, not the new one

More people now ask an assistant what to watch than ask a friend. So we asked ChatGPT six questions about these shows, then asked them again to see which answers held.

ChatGPT · What repeated across runs
CHATGPT ANSWERS, NOVEMBER 11, 2026 · TIMES IT HAPPENED / TIMES ASKEDLeaves Elsbeth off the Kings' shows3 of 3Recommends Elsbeth to Good Wife / Good Fight fans0 of 4Links The Good Wife and The Good Fight4 of 4Sends Elsbeth fans back to the older shows1 of 2Names representation for The Good Fight1 of 2Cites CBS or Paramount+1 of 14Green: same answer every time. Gray: changed between runs.Model gpt-4.1-mini with web search. An assistant's answer varies run to run.

Asked what the Kings have made, it left out Elsbeth all three times, the show that is actually on the air. One answer still called The Good Fight and Evil current, though both have ended. Across both rounds, no recommendation for a fan of the older shows mentioned Elsbeth.

The older shows are tied to each other reliably: asked what to watch after either one, it named the other every time. The link from new to old is shaky. Asked what to watch after Elsbeth, it named both older shows in one round and neither in the other.

The owner is rarely the source. In 14 answers, CBS was cited once and Paramount+ never. The rest came from TMDB, Looper, TV Guide, Wikipedia, IMDb, an eBay poster listing and three Russian- or Ukrainian-language film sites. On why people love The Good Fight, one answer left out the firm at its center and the other listed it fifth of six.

When a Spin-Off Is Yours to Build
  • You are carrying something specific — a character, an ingredient, a feature people already name — not a mood or a tone.
  • The new product has its own reason to be chosen, one sentence long, that is not the parent’s reason.
  • It works for someone who never bought the original, because most of its buyers will not have.
  • You own the thing you are moving, or have the rights to move it written down.

Where those hold, the Kings’ pattern is yours. Where the plan depends on the launch lifting the parent, or on buyers already knowing the parent, it is not, and the budget should be sized for a new product earning its own audience.

Six Lenses
  • CEO One set of characters produced three products across seventeen years and two channels. The asset that travelled was a person on screen, not a tone. Treat the parent as a source of characters and craft, not of customers.
  • CFO Zero of six premieres lifted the parent, so a launch budget justified partly on parent lift is justified on nothing measured. CBS renewed Elsbeth even though it ranked among the network’s lowest-rated scripted shows with adults 18–49. Size each product on the metric its own channel pays for.
  • CRO Politics topped one show at 8 citations and character topped the other at 10, with no overlap at the top. A product with one clear reason to buy is easier to sell than one with two half-reasons. Give each product one reason to be chosen, and keep it different from its sibling’s.
  • CPO Elsbeth borrowed a 1970s format because it suits a weekly broadcast slot. The format was re-tuned to the channel while the character stayed fixed. Keep the recognizable trait and rebuild the format for where the product will live.
  • Legal All three shows sit inside one studio relationship, the Kings’ overall deal with CBS Studios, which is what let a character move freely. A portfolio built across owners would stall at the first move. Write the right to move characters and features into the deal before the first product ships.
  • Risk ChatGPT left the newest show off the Kings’ list three times in three and cited the owner once in fourteen answers. A buyer asking an assistant about the family is being sent to the products that are no longer on sale. Check what assistants say about your portfolio before launch, and publish the page they should be reading.

Reconciled. The CFO and CRO seats agree and the CEO seat explains why: the new product has to earn its own buyer, so give it its own reason and its own budget. The pull comes from Risk, which says the new product will be invisible in the channel where many buyers now start, while the older products keep getting recommended. The course that satisfies all six is to launch the extension as a standalone product with one reason to be chosen, and treat the parent’s owned pages as the place that introduces the new product to assistants and buyers alike.

The Path

Before you launch the extension, measure the parent and ask the machines.

Pull three years of monthly search volume for your parent brand and write down the lift bar you would accept in the launch month. Then ask two or three AI assistants what your company makes and what to buy after your best-known product, three times each, and record whether the new product appears.

What it costs
An afternoon of one analyst’s time and a search-data tool most teams already pay for. The harder cost is committing to the lift bar in writing, which takes the halo argument off the table if it misses.
How you’ll know
The launch month gives a yes or no against the bar within thirty days. The assistant check is working when the new product shows up in two of three answers to “what do they make.”

Know what your portfolio is worth before you extend it.

Before the next launch budget is set, a Decision Brief puts the sourced, dated evidence for that call in one place, with its limits stated. Or commission one built around your own portfolio.

See the Decision Briefs Or commission a custom brief →
This piece discusses publicly reported figures about named companies and markets. It is analysis, not investment, legal or commercial advice, and CULT+MATH has no relationship with any organization named in it.